I don’t have that answer. I agree that each case is different, and your assessment of the two camps seems to be fairly accurate. I myself fall outside of those two groups, (as a mid-late 30’s non obese, non fitness lifestyle person), but share parallels with each. My issues are primarily phycological/ addiction related, and not metabolic. I am overweight, significantly so when out of shape. However I am not categorized as obese by my doctor, but “at risk for longterm health complications if I don’t start building better habits and get my weight in check”. This has been the same assessment from any doctor for the last 10+ years. Up until my mid 20s, I had no issues with weight gain.
I have struggled with alcohol and drug addiction in my past, and at times, it seemed like there was no way out. But I have been able to shift out of that and maintain sobriety for years. Likewise I was smoker for most of my adult life, and have been tobacco free for 5 years, despite feeling like there was no hope after many attempts at quitting. I hope to build similar pathways in my life around food/ binge eating, which is the last frontier for me.
My intention to eventually be non reliant on peptides is a personal mission. For my own reasons, I want to be in control of my life and my actions. Being able to prove to myself that I can do it without medical intervention is a key goal.
That being said, here I am after many attempts without, and you could argue that even if I can get off and sustain without peptides longterm, that it was still medical intervention as a catalyst. I am totally fine with that. I think GLPs are a miracle, and a game changer. I do not have any issue with the idea of taking them for life, and I realize for many, that may be non optional. I do not see getting off of them as a higher ground than staying on them. Again this is a highly personal goal.
Ultimately, to your point, being healthy and keeping the weight off is the most important health consideration. With or without the help of peptides. If I am unable to achieve the goal described, I take no issue with staying on them longterm and won’t hesitate to do so. But not until I’ve tried getting off after reaching my targets first!
That’s my story and I’m sticking to it. To each their own