MountainsoftheMoon said:
In the same boat, questioning the exit strategy.
Historically, without peptides, when I’ve lost weight the old fashioned way: suffering through diet and exercise and forcing myself to abstain from junk food and drinking… I’d get to target weight, feel great, then put it all back on and the cycle would continue…
Those cycles have always been short for me, like 6 months in discipline mode, then 6 months back to the start, then a year or so to get motivated to try again…
I’m planning to stay on it for 1-2 years max, and hoping that the longer term/ sustained fitness and controlled relationship with food will be sufficient retraining. I want to ween off and keep those habits in tact. Hoping that the firmer-established lifestyle will be enough to outcompete the food noise. Ultimately I don’t want to be reliant on peptides forever.
Does there need to be an exit strategy? The biggest advantage GLP medications offer is weight loss maintenance. Not as well researched yet, other than the studies that just kept people on them after the initial trial ended, but in those cases weight loss was very consistently maintained for up to 5 years. Nearly everyone with weight issues has lost weight with diet, exercise and self discipline at some point and nearly every one of those has put the weight back on again. GLP drugs offer an escape from this endless cycle of trying to control something that feels uncontrollable.
Part of the reason for differences in opinion on taking GLP's long term, is there are 2 main categories of people on this forum, some, often older, with long term severe obesity and another group that is typically younger, fitter and less obese. The second group is far less likely to see themselves needing GLP medications long term, which may well be true but it will take another decade to find out for sure, and the first group that is much more likely to stay on them long term, and see them as helping to fix a serious life long problem.
I wish you success in your endeavor to keep the weight of without them, but the question I would ask is why? Being overweight or obese long term has serious adverse health consequences, weight cycling, despite its bad reputation, does actually reduce some of those consequences, but has other disadvantages as well. How many years of going through the weight cycling will it take to convince you that that strategy is not working? ( not a criticism , I got to 65 kg in 2012 and back up to 145 by 2022 ). Staying on GLP's not only reduces health problems due to obesity by reducing weight but also, independently of effects on weight reduces many long term health problems, including diabetes development, heart disease and cancers. So staying on them is not bad for your health , it is beneficial. They are definitely not addictive. So the real issue with staying on them is the sense of being dependent on a medication to help control weight. Which I guess feels like not being in control of it yourself? Trying to reduce doses once weight loss has got to where you want is fine, or even stopping it, although I think this is a genuinely bad idea if the obesity was severe, but the most reasonable and realistic way to do it is with careful monitoring of weight and a willingness to restart or increase doses if weight starts to go up rather than let it get out of control first.
The whole obesity epidemic is a fairly recent phenomena, at least in terms of a large percentage of the population being affected, and there are lots of causes, but ultimately the biggest one is the cheap availability of high calorie, low effort food, at the same time as a decline in everyday physical effort at home or at work. And this was enough to make half the population obese. Better habits do not fix this, they are an attempt to control your own behavior to minimise the damage from a generally obesogenic environment. Parts of this can be controlled, by only buying certain types of food and minimising your exposure to those foods on a daily basis. But probably not enough to solve the problem.
I see GLP medications as an escape from the cycle of weight loss, weight gain and the self loathing that comes with it. This alone is enough to improve quality of life, even if weight loss is not to ideal levels. I may be a bit biased in my thinking that diet and exercise really do not work as a strategy for long term weight loss, it is true that it can, but it really is not common. And I am not suggesting that GLP medications make poor dietary and lifestyle choices a good idea, but there is evidence that dietary choices improve on GLP treatment and from personal experience exercising is much easier, safer and more pleasant without lugging around a lot of extra kilos. And even if someone continues to be sedentary and eat an unhealthy diet, which realistically , given the population is obese to start with is fairly likely, the health benefits from weight loss and the drugs themselves will still happen, maybe not as well as if it was combined with a healthy diet and exercise , but a lot better than nothing.